Certification: The CSPJ excludes 17 judges from 159 cases examined

By NAGO News
3 min read
Seventeen judges must leave the Haitian justice system. The Superior Council of the Judiciary (CSPJ) refused them certification according to results published on Wednesday, September 23, 2026, at the end of a work retreat held from September 7 to 10. Out of the 159 files of judges and prosecutors reviewed, 119 were validated.
The rest of the report shows an unfinished process. Fourteen files are awaiting additional investigations before any decision is made. Two judges were struck off for abandoning their posts, and seven others are invited to retire. The CSPJ has set no deadline to complete the pending files.
The Council remains discreet about the reasons for its refusals. It mainly cites a lack of professional integrity and morality, a broad term that, according to press reports, covers serious misconduct as well as fraud or corruption. No individual reason was made public, and no criminal proceedings were announced against the affected judges.
The most prominent name on the list is Brenord Louicius, dean of the first instance court of Fort-Liberté, capital of the North-East, who was in charge of its administration. According to early reports, the full list of 17 has been published. According to Métropole, most of the excluded judges are substitutes for the public prosecutor and peace judges, particularly in the jurisdictions of Port-au-Prince, Petit-Goâve, Jacmel, and Croix-des-Bouquets. NAGO did not report any public reaction from the excluded judges.
The Petit-Goâve prosecutor's office illustrates both sides of the exercise. Two substitutes and a deputy peace judge from this jurisdiction lost their positions, while the public prosecutor, Jean Hérold Anacius, was certified, according to Métropole.
Certification is based on the law governing the status of judges, published in the Monitor in December 2007. Its Article 70 entrusts the CSPJ, with the Ministry of Justice, the evaluation of judges and members of the prosecution, and Article 69 ties it to competence and integrity. The files are prepared by a technical commission, then decided upon by the Council.
The operation has been ongoing for several years in successive waves. In October 2024, the CSPJ had excluded eleven judges, citing among other things the extortion of litigants and, for some, links with armed gangs. A year later, in October 2025, it refused certification to twelve judges and validated seventy-three files.
A judge excluded is not without recourse. In 2023, the Council had estimated that no appeal process existed. A resolution adopted early 2025 now allows for a review within three months following publication, with a personal hearing before the Council convened. This avenue seems already to be used: two judges that Gazette Haïti counted among the rejects of 2024, Mireille Cherestil Sylvain, an investigating judge in Hinche, and Jean David Moïse Simon, a deputy peace judge in Jeremie, figure this year among the five certified after review, according to Métropole.
The results come at a tense time for justice. Three days earlier, on September 20, Joseph Félix Badio and seventeen former Colombian soldiers indicted in the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse were handed over to the United States despite an order from the investigating judge, a transfer that the CSPJ denounced on September 22, according to early reports. For the authors of this analysis, excluding individuals will not be enough to restore public confidence in the institution.
This article was corrected on October 27, 2026.
Videos
Watch now.
Reporting by Radio Métropole, « Le CSPJ exclu 17 juges du système » (25 septembre 2026)
CSPJ hears from lay judges about difficulties in courtsThe Superior Council of the Judiciary (CSPJ) met on Tuesday, September 29, 2026, with the sitting justices of the peace in the Por…CSPJ Certifies 119 Magistrates from 159 DossiersThe Superior Council of the Judiciary (CSPJ) announced on September 23, 2026, that it had completed its review and certification p…Haitian justice facing impunity and monopoliesThe High Court of Justice, established by decree in April 2025 to handle complex cases related to gangs and corruption, was inaugu…French General François Watrin died 224 years ago in Port-au-Prince224 years ago, on November 22, 1802, General François Watrin died of yellow fever in Port-au-Prince, a few weeks after his arrival…
Comments 0